Friends of OpenJDK Today

Book Review: “Quarkus for Spring Developers”

October 04, 2021


  • Avatar photo
    Erik Costlow

    Erik Costlow was Oracle’s principal product manager for Java 8 and 9, focused on security and performance. His security expertise involves threat modeling, code analysis, and instrumentation of security sensors. ... Learn more

Key Take-Aways

  • Quarkus and Spring are both powerful frameworks.
  • Developers with years of Spring experience can consult side-by-side examples to quickly shift code and tests to Quarkus.
  • Quarkus has moved quickly by leveraging proven technologies from existing Java frameworks and standards.
  • Cloud-Native and Java-Native-Image (GraalVM / Mandrel) combine to run Quarkus apps very quickly.

Quarkus for Spring Developers is a straight-forward guide to enable senior developers to quickly shift their Spring skills to leverage the “supersonic subatomic” Quarkus framework, and junior/mid-level developers to learn two frameworks at once.

The book gets straight to the point of Quarkus’ speed before the first chapter, with the foreword providing a real world testimonial of Quarkus software that many Java developers already use. Calling Quarkus "runtime plus framework," Microsoft Principal Group Manager Martijn Verburg explains:

[Eclipse Adoptium/AdoptOpenJDK] moved our API to use Quarkus, and it’s been brilliant both in developer productivity and performance, serving up to 300 million requests in the past two years from a single small instance.”

The recent Snyk/Azul Java community survey showed AdoptOpenJDK as the most popular distribution, with 45% usage among respondents.

The book provides many annotated and numbered examples of how common development tasks are performed in both frameworks, using numbers to indicate how a developer can connect the code samples between projects. Rather than writing straw-man arguments or contrived hype-squad material that always shows why one framework is always better, the examples represent a proper level of knowledge transfer and comparison between how things are done. While the book is published by Red Hat Developer (the company behind Quarkus), opinionated statements about which technology is "better" is left out in favor of strong technical writing.

Knowing Where to Look

Where applicable, the authors make side-by-side tables that can steer developers towards where to look for certain capabilities:

The book additionally explains how developers can use an optional automated migration tool that analyzes existing Spring applications, using analysis techniques that narrow down specifically which Quarkus features can help in which components.

Quarkus also provides base implementations, Quarkus Extensions for Spring Boot, that help Spring applications migrate slowly rather than requiring an all-at-once replacement.

Clear Annotated Code in Both Frameworks

Quarkus for Spring Developers is broken into several chapters, each of which lays out the similarities and differences of each framework. Chapters select a particular development topic and highlight how the work is handled in Spring and how it is handled in Quarkus.

Chapter 3 on RESTful services provides fully annotated examples of how REST endpoints are annotated between Spring WebFlux, Spring MVC, and Quarkus.

Chapter 4 on Persistence explains a comparison between Java EE / Jakarta EE’s Java Persistence API (JPA) and Hibernate, Spring Data, and Quarkus Panache. Developers familiar with any data access patterns can quickly skim the chapter to either start using Quarkus or quickly move an application's database-oriented classes from Spring to Quarkus.

The chapter articulates the way that Quarkus’ support for reactive programming speeds up microservices. By supporting reactive programming directly in Panache, there are fewer reactive-specific changes needed to support reactive programming when compared to Spring’s R2DBC. The net result is that HotSpot and native-compiled Quarkus applications can run faster and with even less memory than a comparable Spring application.

Chapter 5 on Event Driven Services discusses the role of libraries like Spring Event Handling (with @ServiceActivator) compared against Quarkus Event Handler (with @ConsumeEvent).

Focus on Details and Testing

The authors focus on good development practices overall rather than stopping when the sample code runs. Many chapters provide additional context of how to run Quarkus code via automated tests and what to look for in Quarkus log messages.

Several chapters have a portion dedicated to testing. Teams looking to migrate from Spring Boot to Quarkus can use this to verify smaller portions of the application rather than waiting until the entire application has been migrated.

Chapter 2 on Getting Started with Quarkus summarizes the ability to perform three types of tests: Continuous Testing, Unit Testing, and Native Image Testing.

  • Continuous Testing helps developers while they write and change code of a running application. While Quarkus and Spring both feature class reloading to change functions without reload, Quarkus performs an impact analysis to re-run relevant unit tests that are affected by the change.
  • Unit Testing is similar in both frameworks, however the section explains the role of what’s needed in an @QuarkusTest with regards to dependency injection, mocking, and the connection to Spring’s @SpyBean.
  • Native Image Testing represents any additional tests to verify the Continuous Tests and Unit Tests of the application after it has been compiled to a full native machine binary.

Cloud Native Applications

Quarkus for Spring Developers dedicates a chapter to creating cloud-native applications that run on Kubernetes, Google Cloud, Azure, AWS, and many other cloud environments. The focus of the cloud native chapter is deploying and running applications in the cloud. While Quarkus guides users toward native compilation for faster startup with lower memory, this is not a requirement for deployment and code can still be run with a standard JRE.

The book does not discuss Spring-specific capabilities such as the Azure Spring Cloud, "a fully managed Spring Cloud service, jointly built and operated by VMware." The book similarly leaves out preview features, where Quarkus developers can build a single RESTful Quarkus application that automatically integrates into AWS Lambda and Azure Functions. The result of this is a local web application that can be used during development but then runs in serverless behind an application gateway. Similar preview features for Quarkus Funqy in serverless HTTP are left out.

Instead the chapter focuses more on fully supported similarities between Spring and Quarkus, showing off capabilities like health checks, debugging, configuration management, monitoring, and distributed tracing.

Developers working on cloud native applications may find more helpful information by looking at relevant guides on the Quarkus and Spring documentation, where preview features may play a role.

Get Building with Quarkus

Developers can get to work immediately, prototyping new systems or testing how Quarkus can fit in with existing Spring applications:

Related Articles

View All
  • Book Review: “Help Your Boss Help You”

    Some books were written to be read once and put aside, others to be read thoroughly several times and then to be placed behind glass to be broken in case of emergency.

    This book is of the latter kind—once you’ve read through it a few times, and dipped into the areas that speak to you most, you want to have it nearby both as a PDF and in hard copy format—as a backup just in case you can’t find that PDF at the crucial moment when you really need to have a response at hand in times of crisis.

    Read More
    Avatar photo
    August 13, 2021
  • Book Review: “Java by Comparison”

    The book “Java by Comparison” by Simon Harrer, Jörg Lenhard, and Linus Dietz, promises the reader to become a “Java Craftsman” through the study of 70 examples.

    The book is published by The Pragmatic Bookshelf.

    Each “example” is structured as a before-and-after comparison.

    Read More
    June 02, 2021
  • Book Review: “Seriously Good Software”

    Marco Faella’s book “Seriously Good Software” teaches intermediate Java programmers to write better software, using an entirely different approach.

    I can warmly recommend this book to Java programmers who have learned to code and strive to code well.

    I think it is a particularly rewarding read for computer science students who had several semesters of disjointed knowledge of programming, algorithms, computing systems, and software engineering.

    Read More
    July 22, 2021


  • Avatar photo
    Erik Costlow

    Erik Costlow was Oracle’s principal product manager for Java 8 and 9, focused on security and performance. His security expertise involves threat modeling, code analysis, and instrumentation of security sensors. ... Learn more

Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Highlight your code snippets using [code lang="language name"] shortcode. Just insert your code between opening and closing tag: [code lang="java"] code [/code]. Or specify another language.

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Subscribe to foojay updates:
Copied to the clipboard